Recently updated on November 29th, 2024 at 07:52 pm
So, youâve got a mystery lover in your life? And you’re on a mission to find them the perfect gift? If youâre anything like me, you know that finding the right gift can sometimes feel like solving a mystery itself. But donât worryâIâve done the detective work for you!
Whether they’re obsessed with thrilling novels, escape rooms, or true crime documentaries, Iâve got a list of gifts for mystery lovers that are sure to make them feel like Sherlock Holmes or Nancy Drew. Trust me, as someone who loves a good mystery, these gifts are a total game-changer!
In this post, I’m sharing 30 amazing gifts for mystery lovers that Iâve found after hours of research and personal experience. These gifts range from the latest best-selling mystery books to interactive games and fun detective gadgets thatâll keep them guessing. Whether you’re shopping for a holiday, birthday, or just because, you’re guaranteed to find something theyâll love.
This post may contain affiliate links that earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
Searching for more gift ideas? You’re in luck. I have a post full of recommendations with over 118+ gift ideas. Check out my article on gifts for book lovers here.
Here are the 30 best gifts for mystery lovers
1. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders and Other Cases
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders and Other Cases is a fantastic gift for any murder mystery fan! Itâs like stepping into Sherlockâs shoes and solving the cases yourself.
With each case packed with clues, puzzles, and that classic Victorian London vibe, itâs a perfect blend of storytelling and sleuthing that keeps you hooked. Plus, itâs super fun to play solo or with friends, making it a great way to dive deep into the world of mystery.
2. Agatha Christie Tea and book
A delightful gift combo for any mystery lover. Imagine curling up with a classic whodunit while sipping on a cup of tea that feels straight out of a cozy British murder mystery setting.
The perfect way to immerse yourself in Agatha Christie’s world, blending relaxation with the thrill of unravelling a cunning plot twist.
3. Cozy mystery mug
This mug makes the perfect accessory for those late-night reading sessions or Sunday mornings spent diving into the latest cozy crime caper.
Pair it with a cozy blanket and their favorite novel, and you’ve got a gift thatâs both functional and adorable.
4. Unsolved murder mystery case files investigation
The ultimate gift for anyone who loves a good whodunit! Itâs like being a real-life detective, piecing together clues, analyzing evidence, and cracking the caseâall from the comfort of home.
Trust me, if they love unravelling twisted plots and solving puzzles, theyâll be obsessed with this! Plus, it makes the perfect date-night activity.
5. Unexplained mysteries calendar
An absolute gem! Withdaily tear-off pages packed with true crime, unsolved disappearances, supernatural phenomena, and more.
Each day offers a new dose of suspense and intrigue, perfect for keeping the thrill of the unknown alive right at your desk or kitchen counter.
6. Cozy mystery calendar
You can’t go wrong with a scented candle! This Cozy Mystery candle has notes of Earl Grey tea, brown sugar, and vanilla. The perfect gift for any mystery lover!
It captures that warm, comforting vibe you get from curling up with a good book on a rainy day.
The blend of soothing tea and sweet vanilla creates the most inviting scent, while the hint of brown sugar adds just the right touch of cozy sweetness.
7. 221b Baker Street door passport cover
Do you know a Sherlock fan? This 221B Baker Street door passport cover is a must-have!
The iconic 221B Baker Street door design adds a dash of mystery and sophistication to your travel essentials.
Plus, itâs a subtle way to show off your love for Sherlock Holmes while keeping your passport safe!
8. Murder she wrote tote bag
This tote bag is seriously the cutest gift for any Murder She Wrote fan! Itâs practical, stylish, and lets everyone know that you look up to the ultimate amateur sleuth.
Whether you’re carrying books, groceries, or your latest mystery novel, this tote adds a touch of witty charm and shows off your love for one of TV’s most beloved detectives.
9. Partners in Crime necklace
The Partners In Crime necklace set is just too perfect for best friends who bond over their love of mysteries!
Each half of the heart is hand-stamped and split into two necklaces, so you and your BFF can wear your connection wherever you go.
Whether youâre solving mysteries together or just enjoying a cozy night in, these matching necklaces are a fun and meaningful way to celebrate your friendship!
10. Sipping tea, solving crimes t-shirt
Available in dark grey, purple, and mauve, this shirt is as cozy as it is clever, making it perfect for those laid-back days spent binge-reading your favorite whodunit.
The playful design lets everyone know that youâre all about the finer things in lifeâlike a hot cup of tea and a thrilling mystery to unravel. Itâs stylish, comfy, and totally speaks to your inner detective!
11. Secret decoder ring
A secret decoder ring is such a fun and nostalgic gift for mystery lovers of all ages!
It instantly brings out the inner detective in anyone, making you feel like youâre part of a top-secret mission. Whether youâre cracking codes, sending hidden messages, or just adding a bit of playful mystery to your day, this ring is the perfect accessory.
12. Murder She Wrote cross stitch pattern
The perfect gift for crafty mystery fans! It combines the soothing art of cross-stitching with a tribute to the beloved Jessica Fletcher.
Imagine stitching away while watching reruns of Murder, She Wroteâitâs like the ultimate cozy night in!
4
13. Cozy mystery colouring book
A cozy mystery coloring book is such a charming gift for anyone who loves to relax with a good whodunit! Itâs the perfect way to unwind while indulging in your love for all things mysterious and quaint.
This coloring book lets you bring your favorite mystery settings to life with your own creative touch. Itâs a delightful mix of art and escapism thatâs sure to add a splash of color to any mystery loverâs day!
14. Agatha Christie glass
This Hercule Poirot iced coffee glass is just so perfect for fans of the famous Belgian detective!
Whether youâre sipping iced coffee during a marathon of Agatha Christie mysteries or just enjoying your daily brew, this glass is both practical and a subtle way to show off your love for one of the greatest detectives ever.
15. EXIT: The Abandoned Cabin Escape Room Game
EXIT: The Abandoned Cabin is an awesome gift for anyone who loves a good mystery with a side of brain-teasing fun!
This unique escape room game brings the thrill of a live escape room right into your living room. With puzzles to solve, clues to uncover, and a mysterious cabin to escape from, itâs an immersive experience that keeps you on the edge of your seat.
16. Soft Throw blanket
A soft throw blanket is the ultimate cozy companion for any mystery lover! Whether you’re curled up with a gripping whodunit or watching your favorite detective show, this blanket adds a layer of warmth and comfort that makes those chill moments even better.
Itâs perfect for snuggling up on the couch during a rainy day or adding a cozy touch to your reading nook.
17. 221b Baker Street jumper
The Sherlock Holmes sweatshirt with 221B Baker Street on the front is a must-have for any fan of the legendary detective!
Available in classic colors like sand, black, and navy, itâs a stylish way to showcase your love for Holmes while staying warm and cozy.